Better Bread from the Bread Machine


We have a Cuisinart convection bread machine (CBK-200) that was a given to us for Christmas one year. It is an attractive and well-featured machine, but I haven’t had much loaf success with it. We have had bread machines in the past. The Cuisinart tries to produce a loaf which is horizontal, like a loaf from a conventional pan. Overall Cuisinart’s design was not a good compromise. The wide loaf pan accumulates clumps of unmixed flour on the edges. These remain in the baked loaf, and are inedible and unsightly.


The loaves also come out, usually, concave on the top. They rise high then collapse to produce an ugly loaf with a flavorless crust. I set out to improve on this using 3-factor, 2-state screening design to study the influence of sugar, water, and yeast. Foolishly, I started with the Cook’s Illustrated recipe from the mid 90’s, rather than starting with the Cuisinart book’s recipe.

I hypothesized that our high altitude (1 mile above sea level) was the cause. My results with the Cook’s Illustrated recipe were like the abhorrent results from the Cuisinart book (see results ). I used the results of the screening experiment for guidance by extrapolating the fitted equation along the curve of steepest ascent. Unfortunately, I had two different extrapolation curves–one for height of the loaf at its center and another for the height of the loaf at its edges. One curve said to add more yeast, the other said to add less yeast. So, I read more of the advice available online. Probably I should have spent more time reading at the start. For the sunken loaf problem all advice was consistent: add less sugar, less water, and less yeast, and maybe add more salt.

I used my curve which predicted less yeast to extrapolate the amount of water, and yeast, and sugar. The result of that extrapolation was almost the same amount of sugar and the same amount of yeast recommended in the Cuisinart book. The Duh! moment. However, my prediction wanted less water, much less. The Cuisinart recipe wanted 1.42 flour:water by weight, but my extrapolated recipe wanted only 1.96 flour:water by weight.

I am not done with the experiment yet. Because I autonomously concluded that I should use the same amount of salt and yeast as the Cuisinart recipe, I believe that those factors do not need further exploration. The flour:water ratio, on the other hand, is worth exploring.

Flour and Water

I am horrified by the lack of consistency in the specification of flour weight and volume. One thread indicates that the weight of a fixed amount of flour will change by about 2% due to humidity variation. I’m more than satisfied with 2% accuracy. Measurement by volume, on the other hand, may vary by over 10%.

Because of this variation you would think that the assumed weight of a cup of all purpose flour would be a standard. But no. Consider these sources:

4.25 oz King Arthur
4.375 oz USDA
4.625 oz Gold Medal
4.7 oz
4.75 oz
5 oz Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes
5.5 oz Cook’s Illustrated Rustic Italian Bread (bread flour ~5% denser)

When a recipe says “one cup of flour”, it is talking about somewhere between 4 and 5.5 oz, a variation of +/-15%. The people worrying about the 2% variation due to humidity are clearly insane, since unless the recipe specifies, no recipe reader has much better than 15% accuracy just understanding the author. I use 4.25 oz/C in my recipes.

Since nobody seems to publish actual data on the net, I will. I used dip-level-pour measurement for 17 trials. The sample mean is 4.76 oz, and the sample standard deviation is 0.17 oz.

Num oz Num oz
1 5.00 9 4.50
2 4.80 10 4.65
3 4.70 11 4.65
4 4.80 12 4.75
5 4.90 13 5.05
6 4.65 14 4.80
7 4.50 15 4.80
8 4.65 16 5.05
17 4.75

2 The Recipes

Add the ingredients in the order listed. Set the machine for 1.5 lb loaf, with a light crust. Note: my recipe developed at 1 mile above sea level.

Mine CI Cuisinart
6.5 fl oz 10 fl oz 9 fl oz water, fl. oz.
1 Tbsp 1 Tbsp 2.33 Tbsp oil, tablespoons
1 tsp 1 tsp lemon juice
2 tsp 3 tsp 2.25 tsp granulated sugar, teaspoons
1 tsp 1 tsp 1.125 tsp salt, teaspoons
12.75 oz (3 C) 12.75 (3 C) 3 C flour, C
1/4 C 1/4 C 3 Tbsp nonfat dry milk
1.25 tsp 2 1/4 tsp 1.5 tsp instant yeast

I have tried recipes with 6.5, 7, and 7.5 fl oz of water. Both 6.5 and 7 produced nice loaves, but 7.5 again produced a saggy loaf. This provides a fairly contained range to consider for a response surface method. Though perhaps the next experiment will include some whole wheat.


One thought on “Better Bread from the Bread Machine

  1. I’ve read somewhere it could be caused by too much wather or too much yeast. I’ve similar problem. I use it in manual and i’ve noticed that when start to bake the beautiful round top become flat. And yes I used too much yeast ( mother yeast and beer yeast) . In another test I put less yeast and wait for the grown up, but I add too much whole rye flour and remain little after 10 hour, but the top is convex.
    Some flours absorb more whather than others.
    Some flours are trongher than others indicated by letter W and number or gluten grams (more are mlre strongher)
    The water also is important, CL and CA are a problem.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s